Competition Commission

Cambridge Arts Picturehouse

UPDATED 29/1/15: And Now, The End Is Near, with details of the sale of the Cambridge Cineworld and my final thoughts on the poor handling of the process by the various government organisations involved

UPDATED 27/12/14: State Of The Nation, including the latest update on the sales of affected cinemas

UPDATED: Summary of the final report findings and of the objections to those findings

See the comments section of the above post for the latest updates.

Letter from the Competition Commission in response to my blog posts (21st October 2013)

Response to the Competition Commission’s open letter to me (24th October 2013)

The Competition Commission, at the request of the Office Of Fair Trading, investigated the competition issues surrounding the purchase of City Screen Limited, which runs the Picturehouse cinemas, by Cineworld Group plc. The investigation concluded that three areas – Aberdeen, Cambridge and Bury St. Edmunds – were likely to suffer a substantial lessening of competition (SLC) as a result. Their only solution to the problem was to require Cineworld Group to sell either a Picturehouse or a Cineworld in each area affected. As someone who lives almost halfway between Cambridge and Bury St. Edmunds and relies on the quality and variety that both chains offer – and something which, as someone who’s also been to cinemas of every other major chain in the past two years – I believed that the loss of either could be of serious detriment to the area, and also make compiling this blog significantly more challenging.

Cineworld decided to sell the Picturehouses in Aberdeen and Bury St Edmunds, and thankfully both were purchased by good, reasonably independent buyers who intend to continue to run them in the same manner. At this time, Cineworld are still deciding which one to sell in Cambridge, and the process has taken so long that the Competition Commission no longer exists, having been merged with the Office Of Fair Trading to form the Competition Market Authority. I wrote a number of articles, as did many others, on why I believed this to be wrong and why it should be stopped. Despite all of the activity, the legal process proved frustratingly elusive to challenge for private individuals. Below are the various articles that I wrote during the various stages of the process and the findings being released.

I’ve written at length on the Commission’s initial findings:

The Cineworld / Picturehouse Competition Commission Decision: My Interim Findings

And then, after the publication of the full report, some further thoughts:

The Cineworld / Picturehouse Competition Commission: Brief Thoughts On The Full Report

And a view on why simply selling the Cineworlds rather than the Picturehouses doesn’t solve the problem either:

Competition Commission: Why We Can’t Afford To Lose Cineworld Either

Take One, the independent Cambridge film website and magazine, also have a page with a number of articles, including editorial views and a feature on why running the cinema as a cooperative isn’t practical:

Take One Competition Commission page

There is also a petition to make the Competition Commission aware of the strength of feeling, which can be found here:

Petition to the Competition Commission

And you can read the full reports, findings and proposed remedy to the situation at the Competition Commission website.

Full report into the acquisition of City Screen Limited by Cineworld Group plc

Following the publication of the final report, I consider the questions that remain unanswered and call for further action.

Review of the final report and unanswered questions

Here I explore the economics of the Commission’s decision, and appeal for someone to help explain to me the economics, which I believe are wrong.

A Request For The Competition Commission To Explain Basic Economics To Me

5 thoughts on “Competition Commission

    […] Competition Commission […]

    […] Competition Commission […]

    […] Competition Commission […]

    Review: Boyhood « The Movie Evangelist said:
    August 23, 2014 at 10:02 am

    […] Competition Commission […]

    Cambridge Film Festival 2014 | PenPaperAction! said:
    September 8, 2014 at 9:34 pm

    […] The 34th Cambridge Film Festival (CFF) is done for another year and it’s been a cracking festival, which is especially heartening given the uncertain future of its home, Cambridge Arts Picturehouse, seriously threatened by an earlier ludicrous ruling from the Competition Commission (so who’s still here huh Comp Comm? It’s US!) The situation is still not finally resolved but the story is best read here: […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s